
Creatine and Brain Health, Anxiety Treatments, Depression & More
Season 2026 Episode 2343 | 27m 29sVideo has Closed Captions
Live from Fort Wayne Indiana, welcome to Matters of the Mind hosted by Psychiatrist Jay Fawver, M.D.
Live from Fort Wayne Indiana, welcome to Matters of the Mind hosted by Psychiatrist Jay Fawver, M.D. Now in it's 28th year, Matters of the Mind is a live, call-in program where you have the chance to choose the topic for discussion.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Matters of the Mind with Dr. Jay Fawver is a local public television program presented by PBS Fort Wayne
Cameron Memorial Community Hospital

Creatine and Brain Health, Anxiety Treatments, Depression & More
Season 2026 Episode 2343 | 27m 29sVideo has Closed Captions
Live from Fort Wayne Indiana, welcome to Matters of the Mind hosted by Psychiatrist Jay Fawver, M.D. Now in it's 28th year, Matters of the Mind is a live, call-in program where you have the chance to choose the topic for discussion.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Matters of the Mind with Dr. Jay Fawver
Matters of the Mind with Dr. Jay Fawver is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipGood evening.
I'm psychiatrist Jay Fawver, and welcome to Matters of the Mind.
Matters of the Mind is a weekly call in program where you have the chance to choose the topic for discussion concerning mental health topics.
So if you have any questions that you can want to add to go on the air that I can answer, you may write me a via the internet at MattersOfTheMind - all one word - @wfwa.org.
That's MattersOfTheMind@wfwa.org.
And if you can call or text during this program, you are welcome to do so.
And let's start tonight's program with an email I recently received.
And it reads Dear Dr.
Fawver, how does creatine supplementation 5g to 20g daily impact the brain and mental health?
Creatine has had a lot of study over the past ten years, especially for muscle development, and it's been found that as people get older, they tend to have less creatine available.
Creatine does come from our diets.
We get maybe 1 or 2g of creatine every day in our diets, and you're talking about 5 or 20g every day.
20g a day is not commonly used for loading up for maybe a week or so, and then people will often drop down to 5g or 5g twice a day for creatine supplementation.
So what's creatine due to the brain?
Creatine theoretically goes to the brain.
It will stimulate two of the five dopamine receptors.
So it's not really standard practice to add on creatine supplementation to antidepressant medications.
Although I'm aware of one study where creatine added to antidepressants did seem to help.
So, you know, you could add five grams maybe once or twice a day safely.
Always check it out with your primary care clinician first before doing that.
I would warn you about creatine supplementation.
Creatine breaks down to creatinine, and when creatine breaks down to creatinine, creatinine can go higher in the body.
Now that's not a huge problem, except if you're getting a blood test looking at your kidney functioning, because a measure of kidney functioning will be how well your body will get rid of creatinine.
So high creatinine build up in the blood test says, oh my goodness, maybe you have kidney problems because you're not getting rid of creatinine.
Well, that's if you're taking creatine supplementation.
That could be the problem there.
So I recommend that if you're taking creatine supplementation by all means stop it at least one week and preferably two weeks before you get any blood test looking at your kidney functioning.
But creatine supplementation can be beneficial, especially for older people, for concentration, memory, attention span.
They've actually used creatine supplementation for people who have endured traumatic brain injury, for people who have Parkinson's disease, and in some cases, people who have Alzheimer's dementia.
Because creatine seems to have an activating effect, it creatine tends to help the manufacturing of our natural energy in our brain, called ATP.
And ATP is in our brain, and our rest of our body and creatine will help that develop.
So creatine can be somewhat energizing in that regard.
But the biggest issue with creatine is it does break down to creatinine, in which case you want to stop creatine at least I'd say two weeks before a blood test.
Looking at kidney functioning.
Thanks for email.
Let's go to our first caller.
Hello, Art, welcome to Matters of the Mind.
Art.
You had a question about taking gabapentin and buspirone or BuSpar together.
You can, art.
Gabapentin is a medication that was originally approved for seizures back in the 1980s.
And what it does, it will basically modulate or dampen the itchy trigger finger on nerves.
Now nerves when you have restless leg syndrome, when you have pain, when you have anxiety, when you have difficulty with sleep, sometimes they'll have an itchy trigger finger and they'll allow too much calcium to inflow into the nerve.
And that's what fires off the nerve.
What gabapentin will do is just dampen down that itchy trigger finger of the nerves, and it can help thereby with seizures.
It can help with anxiety, sleep, pain, a lot of different type of symptoms.
It can improve.
Buspirone or BuSpar is entirely different, Art.
BuSpar will give you a an effect on this particular serotonin receptor.
There's 14 serotonin receptors.
One of them is called serotonin one A and BuSpar basically will give you an effect on the on the dimmer switch on serotonin one A receptors.
So by dampening the dimmer switch it'll just control how much serotonin is affecting that particular receptor.
And what BuSpar does primarily, Art, is it'll help with worry.
So it helps with ruminative worry where you're dwelling on things, you're thinking about what if, what if, what if.
Gabapentin on the hand will help with anxiety itself, will help with sleep.
It will give you more symptomatic relief.
BuSpar came out in 1985.
I believe it came out about two years after Xanax did, and a lot of people thought that it would replace Xanax.
It's entirely different from Xanax.
Xanax will affect chloride channels and dampen the influx of chloride, which calms down the brain very quickly.
Gabapentin will help on the calcium channel side.
BuSpar works on the serotonin side, so Xanax, BuSpar, gabapentin all work differently.
And BuSpar didn't work that well compared to Xanax.
For panic attacks and for really severe blasts of anxiety people might endure.
BuSpar tends to work best if you take it to sometimes three times a day, every day, ongoing, mainly for ruminative worry.
Now, why would people take a medication where you had to take it 2 or 3 times a day?
Well, a lot of college students tend to do well with BuSpar or buspirone.
College students will get so anxious that their anxiety volume control.
Right here in the brain, it's called the amygdala.
Their anxiety volume control will get so enhanced that it will shut down their thinking part of the brain in the front.
In other words, if you have overwhelming anxiety, it will hijack the thinking part of your brain.
So what you do with BuSpar you're trying to dampen down with your little dimmer switch there, your dimmer control, you're trying to dampen that down a little bit so you can think more clearly and have less anxiety without sedation, or even what's called cognitive impairment that we often see with medications like Xanax, Klonopin and the medications will very profoundly help with anxiety, but they can cause you to have difficulty with thinking.
So that's where we'll often use BuSpar and gabapentin together.
If you have anxiety, if you have worry in combination, gabapentin and BuSpar can work very well side by side.
Thanks for your call.
Let's go to our next caller.
Hello, John.
Welcome to Matters of the Mind.
John.
You've asked you said you've heard me use the word cognitive.
I think I just used the word cognitive.
What is cognition and what can affect cognition?
John.
When I say cognitive or cognition, I'm talking about four pillars of our thinking, okay?
I'm talking about attention span, memory.
I'm talking about speed of processing your brain's internet speed.
And I'm also thinking about executive functioning where you're able to think and make decisions.
All those aspects are controlled by different parts of the brain.
So you've got attention span, memory, speed of processing, and you've got executive functioning.
That's cognition, four pillars of cognition.
And we'll have different features that can affect cognition.
For instance, when people get depressed they'll have difficulty specifically with speed of processing.
So they'll have trouble with slow internet speed.
They'll just feel like their brain just doesn't function quickly enough.
They can't go from one task to another to another.
Some medications, for instance, make that worse.
A medication like vortioxetine, also known as Trintellix, has actually been shown to improve speed of processing when somebody has depression.
So depression can make speed of processing very specifically much worse.
Attention span.
Classically, attention deficit disorder will cause you to have trouble with attention span.
So can various other medical conditions like sleep apnea, hypothyroidism, low iron diabetes can cause you trouble with attention span.
You can have difficulty with memory with Alzheimer's dementia.
Obviously, we could also have trouble with short term and immediate memory, with various other medical conditions that can be problematic for people and executive functioning.
You can have trouble with decision making, with mood swings and various mood disorders, and you can have difficulty with decision making if the front part of your brain is being impacted in any way.
So if somebody has a head injury or a concussion, they can have trouble specifically with executive functioning, where they will indeed have difficulty with making decisions.
So the four pillars of cognition are attention span, memory speed of processing of the thinking, and the fourth being executive functioning.
Thanks for your call.
Let's go.
Next email question.
Our next email question reads.
Dear Dr.
Fawver, I'm lucky to have lots of well-meaning friends and family who do their best to help me when I deal with anxiety and depression.
How do I express to them that I don't want them to try to fix me or be amateur therapists?
What should I be asking for from friends?
I would thank your friends and family if their well-meaning, as you had mentioned, their well-meaning.
By all means thank them for for expressing their concerns because I'll tell you about the other people friends, family, your spouse.
They can tell something's not right with you before you even realize it.
I would simply listen to what they have to say.
If they're expressing concerns about you, simply ask what they're seeing.
That might be different.
Yeah.
If they are expressing some psychotherapeutic concepts that might not be going down the right track, I would suggest that you find a counselor or a therapist who could maybe help you, and you could tell them that you're dealing with those kind of issues with your therapist, but if they're seeing particular issues that might be seen as being problematic, it's important for you to listen to them and hear what they have to say about all those types of things.
Thanks for your email.
Let's go to our next caller.
Our next caller.
Is Jack.
Jack, here he had mentioned.
I've heard that there's an increase in placebo effect with psychiatric medications.
Does that mean it's easier to get psychiatric medications approved in clinical trials?
It's actually more difficult to get psychiatric medications approved in clinical trials.
Now, Jack, because with clinical trials, yeah, you have a placebo effect, which is a sugar pill.
So you have a placebo involved in clinical trials, and you have the active medication.
You're trying to get approved for whatever condition.
And it takes up to $1 billion to get a medication FDA approved, because you go through three different phases of trials before it gets to market.
The first trial will be just a very small trial looking at the safety of the medication.
The second set, the phase two, the second set of trials will be where you're comparing the medication to a moderate number of people versus placebo, looking for how well it works versus placebo.
And you have to separate away from placebo.
In other words, placebo will give everybody some effect.
But when you have an active drug, you try to get approved.
You've got to separate away from placebo significantly to the point where it would be predictably not likely to to be superior to placebo in at least 95 out of 100 cases.
And they call that statistical significance.
And nowadays there are actually looking for clinical significance, which goes beyond statistical significance, because clinical significance means that the patient, as well as the clinician can tell a profound difference in how you're doing versus the people who are on placebo.
Here's what's been going on for the past 20 years.
In psychiatry, the placebo effect has been enhanced significantly.
In other words, back in the 1990s, when I was first practicing in psychiatry, there was a lot of skepticism about psychiatry.
And I started this program back in 1998.
And at that time, a lot of people were even questioning the validity of my field in psychiatry.
Well, that's changed dramatically in the past 25 years because now people have understanding, they have hope, they have expectations with psychiatric medications.
They're much more knowledgeable about psychiatric medications now compared to 1990s.
So a lot of people go into a clinical trial for a psychiatric medication now expecting to get the real drug and expecting to feel better.
So placebo effects in psychiatric clinical trials in the past 25 years have increased dramatically.
So it's more difficult to get the active drug to separate away from placebo.
And there's some really good medications out there who didn't separate away from a placebo enough, not because they didn't work.
It's just that the placebo arm did so well.
So choosing a research study group is kind of like jury selection.
You have to get people who aren't going to be overly enthusiastic about joining a study, because those people are more likely to get a really dramatic placebo effect.
You want to get people in research studies who are more objective about what they're noticing, good or bad, about anything, so it's more difficult to separate it from placebo in 2026.
And I think it's more difficult to get medications approved now, probably primarily because of that.
In Europe, they do compare medications versus active medications that are already approved on the market.
But at this point, we are mainly looking at medications versus placebo in the United States.
Thanks for your email.
Let's go to our next caller.
Hello, Jim.
Welcome to Matters of the Mind.
Jim, you had mentioned that you've seen ads for brain stimulants like NeuroCube.
Cube.
What's your take on these and how do they work?
I want a stimulant medications out there.
Jim, I wouldn't necessarily encourage your use of those simply because many of them are.
They have stimulant herbs in them and they might have caffeine in them.
I'm not finding that brain stimulus are that effective for a lot of people.
I know there's a lot of people getting excited about them, but I wouldn't recommend them, and I wouldn't recommend them because I wouldn't take them myself.
So I always tell people, you want to ask your primary care clinician, your specialist, for that matter, are they taking any supplements themselves?
Because we'll be the first ones to take a supplement for any particular condition.
And if there's a medication, it can help.
You think I'd be the first one to want to use it, but I'm just not finding a lot of excitement about these so-called neurotrophic medications that are considered to be brain stimulants to help with cognition and so forth.
They have various supplements in them, but I'm just not finding a lot of benefit from them.
I see a lot of the supplementation excitement come and go.
Now.
I mentioned creatine earlier.
I take creatine, so to give full disclosure there, but I think creatine is going to be around to stay.
But some supplements like ginseng, a lot of people said I've never heard of ginseng.
Well, ginseng was really popular back in the 1990s.
That was the herb.
And that was the supplement to take for cognition and memory.
I haven't heard about anybody taking ginseng for a long time now.
So a lot of these herbs and a lot of excitements concerning the so-called neurotrophic medications, it'll kind of fade over the course of time because people find that they're not that effective in general.
Thanks for your call.
Let's go to the next email.
Our next email reads, Dear Dr.
Fawver, do people get more sensitive to criticism when they have clinical depression?
They actually do.
People are more sensitive to criticism when they have clinical depression, because this part of the brain here, it's called the dorsal medial prefrontal cortex.
The dorsal medial prefrontal cortex is right in here.
That part of the brain increases in its activity when you get depressed.
And you might think, oh, the brain's increasing in its activity, that's a good thing.
No it's not.
If it increases its activity too much, you are super sensitive to what other people might, how you perceive other people and what they say to you, how they look at you.
And it's almost to the point where being paranoid, but it's not psychotic.
This happens with people clinical depression who do not have psychotic features.
They get very sensitive to other people's comments, and they're often thinking or saying, what did you mean by that?
And they're easily offended that dorsal medial prefrontal cortex, dorsal means it's up here.
And medial means it's in the middle of the brain.
The dorsal medial prefrontal cortex is important for social cognition.
So in other words it helps you kind of gauge the your social connectedness with other people.
And it can be highly influenced when people particularly are depressed.
Now it actually interestingly enough, the dorsal media prefrontal cortex will decrease in activity drastically when a woman has postpartum depression.
What's that do?
Well, she doesn't care about whether people think of her.
She doesn't particularly care about how other people are responding to her.
Her social context diminishes significantly.
So the dorsal medial prefrontal cortex decreases in activity when a woman has postpartum depression.
That's part of the reason why she has more of a detachment from her baby.
There's less bonding and there's less engagement with her husband or her significant other.
So the dorsal media prefrontal cortex is basically there to help you gauge social context and gives you social context cognition, as we call it.
Now, underneath the dorsal medial prefrontal cortex is this particular part of the brain called the ventral medial prefrontal cortex.
The ventral meaning it's under the dorsal one.
But the ventral medial prefrontal prefrontal cortex is where you establish your values and you establish your moral, your moral context of activity around you.
And it's kind of allowing you to determine what your identity is as a person.
And it allows you to, from a cognitive standpoint, determine the difference between right and wrong as you understand it.
So it's more ingrained.
That's the ventral medial prefrontal cortex where it's more individualized.
The dorsal medial prefrontal cortex is highly influenced by other people.
And they kind of work in tandem because they're right beside each other.
Thanks for your email.
Let's go to our next caller.
Hello, Leah.
Welcome to Matters of the Mind.
Leah, you want to know the difference between atypical and typical antipsychotic medications?
Atypical antipsychotic medications came out in the early 1990s.
The clozapine was being studied right down there in Indianapolis back in the 1970s, 1980s.
And clozapine was the the first of the atypical ones, and it was followed by risperidone.
And after that it was quetiapine.
And I take the back after that was a olanzapine, which is known as Zyprexa.
And then you had quetiapine two years later, which is Seroquel.
These atypical psychotic medications had less effect on dopamine itself.
Now the typical antipsychotic medications, how did they work?
They blocked dopamine.
And that's all they did.
They blocked dopamine.
And they did so in the limbic system, the side part of the brain here.
That is important for determining if things around you are real or not real.
If you have excessive dopamine transmission in the limbic system, you can hear voices talking to you very clearly.
Even though there's nobody around.
You could have trouble with processing your thoughts.
You could have trouble with with intrusive thoughts, all sorts of difficulties that we are we now call schizophrenia when people are having excessive dopamine activity in the limbic system.
By contrast, the atypical antipsychotic medication will have less effect on dopamine.
They'll have some dopamine blockade, but they primarily will block serotonin two receptors in the frontal lobe.
If you block serotonin two way receptors in the frontal lobe, you increase dopamine in the frontal lobe and you think, well, maybe too much dopamine in the frontal lobe.
That's not good.
Well, it's not too much dopamine.
It's enough dopamine to help you think and help you concentrate.
So the atypical antipsychotic medications are better for mood, concentration, motivation, energy.
A lot of people with schizophrenia, especially when you give them dopamine blockers as a means of with the typical psychotic medications, they'll complain.
They can't think, they can't concentrate, they don't feel alive.
So what do they do?
They smoke cigarettes.
And at one point, 70% of people with schizophrenia smoked cigarettes, nicotine cigarettes.
And they did so because they were trying to offset some of the dulling effect they were getting from the typical psychotic medications.
So over the course of the past 25 years, we've seen decreased need for people with schizophrenia treated with atypical antipsychotics, medications.
There's less need for them to smoke cigarettes because they don't need the effect of the nicotine so much anymore.
Thanks for your call.
Let's go to our next text.
Text is from Tom from Columbia City.
Hello, Tom.
You have you want to know what are some ways to deal with anxiety other than medication?
The best way to deal with anxiety, Tom, is to identify the source of the anxiety.
So if you have an anxious situation at the workplace, at home, deal with the source first.
If there's a particular stimulant, there's a particular stimulus causing you to feel anxious.
Secondly, just what can you do from a from a livelihood standpoint?
Make sure you're getting enough sleep.
Don't stay up at night worrying about the sources of your anxiety.
So in other words, try to deal with your anxiety earlier in the day and I often come off and advise people to take a take a notebook and create a worry diary out of.
In other words, write down your worries and write them down maybe once a week if you want to.
Every day.
That's great.
Write down your worries, take a good look at them and determine what you can or can't do about them.
And if you can do something about them, formulate a plan for how you're going to address them.
But if you can't do anything about them, you know you got to let them go and then come back to looking at those worries.
Three months from now, six months from now, even a year from now, you're going to find that a lot of worries that you had today aren't that big of a deal a few months from now.
So it reassures you, assures you that the worries you have today, somehow some way, will work themselves out in such a way that you're not going to be worrying about those particular issues in the future.
So I certainly suggest finding the source of your worry, making sure you get enough sleep and go to bed every night at the same time as you can, get up at the same time every morning.
You know you've had enough sleep.
If you don't need an alarm to get up, if you don't need an alarm to get up, you know you've had enough sleep.
So make sure you get enough sleep.
Keep a worry diary and very, very importantly, try to get some kind of physical activity.
Physical activity is remarkable for anxiety in general.
Generally we talk about aerobic and anaerobic activity.
Anaerobic activity is where you will run, youll bike.
You do something, get your heart rate going because if you can increase your heart rate while exercising with anaerobic activity, you can increase this particular release of this chemical called Atrial Natriuretic Peptide, ANP.
ANP increases from your heart.
And that thereby goes to will help the brain function and it slows down your heart rate.
That's why when people are regularly exercising, their heart rate will increase.
It's because the atrial natriuretic peptide is increasing and that can be helpful dramatically for anxiety.
Exercise is also very good for increasing GABA.
GABA as well as glutamate.
So if you increase GABA, you will have a calming effect when you're exercising.
You also increase glutamate.
Glutamate is the accelerator on the brain.
So GABA is the break on the brain.
Glutamate is the accelerator on the brain.
When you exercise you increase both GABA and glutamate.
And that's why people will say after the exercise they feel calmer, but yet they feel more energized.
You feel both as long as you didn't overdo it.
Now what's overdoing it?
Different for different people.
Some people are fine with 15 minutes on an exercise bike.
Other people don't notice significant impact for exercise until they get to 30 to even 40 minutes.
If you go over an hour, you might be overdoing it in some cases.
And if you're training for something, that's fine, but just general exercise on a day to day basis, 30 to 40 minutes would be fine.
More days than not generally.
Now you could always say five days a week, three days a week.
But I just tell people more days than not try to get some kind of exercise in and alternate between the anaerobic exercise with the walking, biking, elliptical, whatever.
Alternate between that and resistance training.
I mentioned creatine earlier.
Creatine is enhanced by the weight training, the resistance training, the the anaerobic exercise.
That can be very helpful.
So aerobic exercise would be where you're getting your heart rate going.
You're you're biking, you're walking, you're running.
You're on the elliptical.
Anaerobic activity would be where you are using weight training and resistance.
And using a combination of those is very, very important, especially when people have mood or anxiety disorders.
But you can imagine the challenge with all of that.
When people have difficulty with anxiety or depression, they often don't have the motivation to exercise.
But remember, you'll feel better after you do it, so you just have to get to it.
Thanks for your email.
Let's go to our last email.
Our last email reads.
I'm building a house and I have mood swings called bipolar disorder.
What colors should I use and what color should I avoid?
I've consulted with building of psychiatric hospitals and even jails years ago in terms of what colors to avoid.
So if you have mood swings, okay, you're having manic highs, perhaps where you're not eating to sleep, you're going from one topic to another to another.
You're socially intrusive for people.
So you probably want to avoid reds, yellows, oranges, bright colors.
They could be very cheerful, but if you're prone to having irritability and even aggression, reds, orange, oranges, and yellows can be problematic for people.
Preferentially, you want to go with blues and greens and off whites in general.
Maybe light beiges, something like that, but blues and greens are often more calming for a lot of people.
And reds, yellows and green reds, yellows and oranges are often a little bit more activating and will enhance more irritability for some people.
Thanks for your email.
I'm out of time for this evening.
If you have any questions that I can answer online, you may write me via the internet at MattersOfTheMind - all one word - @wfwa.org.
I'm psychiatrist Jay Fawver, and you've been watching Matters of the Mind on PBS.
God willing and PBS willing, I'll be back again next week.
Thanks for watching.
Good night.

- Drama

Benjamin Wainwright stars as Maigret in the contemporary adaptation of Georges Simenon's novels.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode

New Episode
New Episode





Support for PBS provided by:
Matters of the Mind with Dr. Jay Fawver is a local public television program presented by PBS Fort Wayne
Cameron Memorial Community Hospital